Lids Reads
Cover of The Wife Upstairs

Thriller

The Wife Upstairs

★★★★★ 1/5

Finished March 23, 2026 · audio

A misleading comp is its own category of crime.

Terrible. Sold as a modern Jane Eyre, but nothing about this resembles Jane Eyre except the names and the fact that there’s a living ex-wife somewhere.

Jane Eyre is such a good gothic, atmospheric classic. It’s so dark and unexpected. I love the idea of a modern version that’s smart and equally dark and gothic. This one was just trashy thrills, and not even very good ones. There was nothing smart or interesting about it.

A misleading comp is its own category of crime.

Vibes

  • a misleading comp
  • a living ex-wife somewhere
  • trashy thrills

Why I picked it up

Sold as a modern Jane Eyre.

Would recommend to

No one.